On June 7, 2004, Garcia was arrested by the Somerton Police Department for sexual conduct with a minor. On October 26, 2004, Garcia pled guilty to attempted sexual conduct with a minor in the Yuma County Superior Court and he was sentenced to lifetime probation.
On August 8, 2005, Garcia was arrested for violation of probation and sentenced to the Arizona Department of Corrections. He was released on October 3, 2013 and is currently on parole.
Garcia is a level 2 sex offender.
Offenders are categorized in three levels. Level 1 is a low risk to reoffend, Level 2 an intermediate risk and Level 3 a high risk.